First time cooking a locally raised free-range turkey? Here’s everything you need to know.
Sap Bush Hollow is sold out of turkeys for 2022….But don’t forget that we’ll be holding a special online blanket sale Thanksgiving weekend on all our gorgeous wool blankets…And we’ll ship anywhere!
Click here to explore the blankets (they’ll all be 20% off when you order online Black Friday). (But remember: we’re a small farm, so our stock is limited!)
And now we come to the final poultry harvest of the year: the pasture-raised turkeys. For over twenty years now, our family has been raising turkeys out on pasture. We have gone from being a quirky local anomaly, to just one of thousands of independent, small, ecologically-focused farmers who are making turkeys available to their neighbors around the country.
Every year at this time I am reminded how this local food movement is really growing and taking hold of our culture, and I am filled with gratitude as more and more folks beat a path to a local farmer. And as more and more of you prepare to celebrate with a local pasture-raised turkey for the first time, this list of tips becomes increasingly in-demand.
So here it is, this year’s Pastured Turkey Cooking Tips, once more revised and updated based on the questions and dilemmas you wrote to me about last year. And this year, as bonus content, we’ve done a quick 5 minute video to demonstrate how to cook it:
As I do every year, I will be sure to check your comments and emails to respond to any concerns you may have about preparing your holiday bird. Then, I will be sure to include that information in next years’ tips. Have a wonderful time preparing for your feast!
PASTURED TURKEY COOKING TIPS
Helpful hints for when you buy (and roast) your first pasture-raised Thanksgiving turkey
Please note that both Long Way on a Little and The Grassfed Gourmet cookbooks, contain my easiest, most delicious turkey recipes ever. They are available through all major online channels, but if you want to support the author directly ;-), you can buy a copy here.
1.Please be flexible. If you are buying your pasture-raised turkey from a small, local, sustainable farmer, thank you VERY much for supporting us. That said, please remember that pasture-raised turkeys are not like factory-farmed birds. Outside of conscientious animal husbandry, we are unable to control the size of our Thanksgiving turkeys. Please be forgiving if the bird we have for you is a little larger or a little smaller than you anticipated. Cook a sizeable quantity of sausage stuffing if it is too small (here’s a recipe), or enjoy the leftovers if it is too large. If the bird is so large that it cannot fit in your oven, simply remove the legs before roasting it.
2. Balk about the price in private. Look, I’m not going to lie. If you are used to picking up a free turkey from the grocery store, then the $5-$8 per pound ticket on a pastured turkey seems expensive. If you’ll notice, however, the farmer selling it isn’t exactly getting rich off you. He or she is selling it based on the farm’s expenses (and grain, labor and processing are VERY expensive these days!) Factory birds from the grocery store are not cheap, either. The price is a ruse. You pay for industrialized food ahead of time through your taxes. I guarantee that, once you get home, experience the amazing flavor, the ease of cooking it and the fact that you don’t suffer gastrointestinal illness after (as so many folks do with factory farmed birds), you will agree the price was worth it.
3.Know what you are buying. If you don’t personally know the farmer who is growing your turkey, take the time to know what you are buying! “Pastured” is not necessarily the same as “free-range.” Some grass-based farmers use the word “free-range” to describe their pasture-raised birds, but any conventional factory farm can also label their birds “free-range” if they are not in individual cages, and if they have “access” to the outdoors – even if the “outdoors” happens to be feces-laden penned-in concrete pads outside the barn door, with no access to grass. “Pastured” implies that the bird was out on grass for most of its life, where it ate grass and foraged for bugs, in addition to receiving some grain.
4.Brining and Basting optional. If tradition dictates that you season your meat by brining your bird and basting it as it roasts, by all means, do so. However, many people brine and baste in order to keep the bird from drying out. With a pastured bird, this is not necessary, and basting only wastes energy as you continually open the oven door. Pastured birds are significantly juicier and more flavorful than factory farmed birds. You can spare yourself this extra step as a reward for making the sustainable holiday choice! (By the way, those turkey roasting bags are not necessary, either.)
5.Monitor the internal temperature. Somewhere along the line, a lot of folks came to believe that turkeys needed to be roasted until they had an internal temperature of 180 degrees Fahrenheit. Yuck. You don’t need to do that. Your turkey need only be cooked to 165 degrees. If the breast is done and the thighs are not, take the bird out of the oven, carve off the legs and thighs, and put them back in to cook while you carve the breast and make your gravy. That entire holiday myth about coming to the table with a perfect whole bird and then engaging in exposition carving is about as realistic as expecting our daughters will grow up to look like Barbie (and who’d want that, anyhow?). Just have fun and enjoy the good food.
6.Cook the stuffing separately. I know a lot of folks like to put the stuffing inside their holiday birds, and if Thanksgiving will be positively ruined if you break tradition, then stuff away. However, for a couple reasons, I recommend cooking your stuffing separately. First, everyone’s stuffing recipe is different. Therefore, the density will not be consistent, which means that cooking times will vary dramatically. If you must stuff your bird, allow for about 12-15 minutes per pound cooking time, but be assiduous about monitoring the internal temperature of the meat and the stuffing. Due to food safety concerns, I happen to think it is safer to cook the stuffing outside the bird. Plus, it is much easier to lift and move both the bird and the stuffing when prepared separately, and to monitor the doneness of each. Rather than putting stuffing in my bird’s cavity, I put in aromatics, like an onion, carrot, garlic and some fresh herbs. When the bird is cooked, I add these aromatics to my stock pot. The aromatics perfume the meat beautifully, and the only seasoning I wind up using on the surface is melted butter, salt and pepper.
7.Do not cover your bird! Covering it will only make the skin rubbery and soggy. Do not put tin foil over the breast. It is an unnecessary waste of aluminum.
8.No need to flip. I used to ascribe to that crazy method of first roasting the bird upside down, then flipping it over to brown the breast. The idea was that the bird would cook more evenly, and the breast wouldn’t dry out. When I did this, the turkey came out fine. But I suffered 2nd degree burns, threw out my back, ruined two sets of potholders and nearly dropped the thing on the floor. Pasture-raised turkeys are naturally juicy. Don’t make yourself crazy with this stunt. Just put it in the oven breast-side up like you would a whole chicken, don’t cover it and don’t over-cook it. Take it out when the breast is 165 degrees (see above). If, despite the disparaging comments above, you still want to show off the whole bird, then bring it into the dining room, allow everyone to ooh and aah, then scuttle back to the kitchen, and proceed as explained above.
9.Be ready for faster cook times. Pasture-raised turkeys will cook faster than factory-farmed birds. Set the oven temp for 325 degrees and figure on 8-10 minutes per pound for an un-stuffed bird, 12-15 minutes per pound if stuffed. Don’t worry — It WILL brown! But remember: oven temperatures and individual birds will always vary. Use an internal meat thermometer to know for sure when the bird is cooked. For more help with cooking your turkey, don’t forget to refer to Long Way on a Little or The Grassfed Gourmet by Shannon Hayes. What?!? You don’t own a copy yet? Click here for hard copies, and here for ebooks. (Yes, shameless promotion of my cookbooks is a part of this annual holiday post.)
10.Use a good-quality roasting pan. If this is your first Thanksgiving and you do not already own a turkey roasting pan and cannot find one to borrow, treat yourself to a really top-quality roaster, especially if you have a sizeable bird. Cheap aluminum pans from the grocery store can easily buckle when you remove the bird from the oven, potentially causing the cook serious burns or myriad other injuries in efforts to catch the falling fowl. Plus, they often end up in the recycling bin, or worse, landfills. If you buy a good quality large roasting pan, and you happen to have a copy of Long Way on a Little and/or The Grassfed Gourmet Cookbook (another shameless hint), I guarantee you will have multiple uses for the pan!
11.Pick the meat off the bird before making stock. If you plan to make soup from your turkey leftovers, be sure to remove all the meat from the bones before you boil the carcass for stock. Add the chunks of turkey back to the broth just before serving the soup. This prevents the meat from getting rubbery and stringy. For an extra-nutritious stock, follow the advice offered in Long Way on a Little.
12. Yes! You can cook a half turkey!!! Being as it’s 2020, many of you might be suddenly faced with reduced numbers around your Thanksgiving table. If you ordered a larger bird than you can now eat, many farmers are able to split your bird in half for you..But don’t wait until the last minute! Ask them as soon as possible so they can plan accordingly! With two half birds, you can roast one (at the same rate as you would a whole bird), and freeze the other for another feast.
13. Help is available. In recent years, our home seems to have become the unofficial Pasture-Raised Thanksgiving Hotline. Please do not hesitate to write to me with your questions at email@example.com. I make a point of checking email three times a day right up through Thanksgiving Day (I stop around noon), so that I can promptly respond to your questions or concerns. Please make sure you write “turkey question” in your subject heading so that I spot it quickly. Enjoy your holiday!
My pasture-raised turkey was tough last year. How do I make sure it doesn’t happen again?
Are you roasting too hot and fast? I recommend 325, but I’ve seen recommendations for 400, which would be way too hot. Other than that, my next questions for a tough bird would start with processing and raising. That doesn’t help you for this year, but it might help for next year:
1. Were the birds stressed at processing? Did people have to chase them to catch them before killing them? Birds should be quietly herded to the processing site and closed into a small enough area where they can be easily picked up and lifted into killing cones. If they are chased and stressed, that will cause a problem. Also, how were they killed? Were their heads chopped off, or were they put into properly-sized killing cones with an incision to the neck? That old head-chopping practice is not the way to go.
2. How old were they? Some folks raise heritage birds and, because they are small, start raising them in May. The birds are often too old by Thanksgiving, making them tougher. For a nice tender bird, they should be starting out in July.
3. Were they fed regularly? Did they have constant access to water while they were being raised? If the farmer allowed the water to run dry during the day, this could result in tougher meat.
4. And finally, how was the pasture? Were the grasses lush, or were the turkeys just out foraging on slim pickings, relying on grain as their primary diet? If they weren’t getting enough grass, then that could make them more like a conventional bird and less like a pastured one.
How long can you hold it fresh?
As farmers, our customers often ask how long someone can keep a whole turkey fresh before cooking for the big day. What is your opinion?
Held in a refrigerator, we tell folks the birds can be cooked fresh up to 9-10 days after processing. Alternatively, if a farmer has good thermostats on his or her freezer, turkeys can be held at 32 degrees indefinitely, then sold as fresh. At this temperature, the turkeys don’t actually freeze through, and the meat quality doesn’t deteriorate. This would allow the farmer to process the birds at an earlier date (really helpful if they’re growing super fast…very few people appreciate 30 pound turkeys), then hold them until the traditional pick-up date.
Different Cook Time Recommended
I see your article recommends cooking 8-10 mins per lb. I have a 17.7lb turkey ,which sounds like it should be no more than 3 hours, but the wrapping from the farm says 14-18lb turkeys should cook 3 1/2 to 4 1/2 hours. What are your thoughts?
If it’s truly a pastured turkey, then it’ll cook at the faster rate. However; if you want to hedge your bets, you can use the ‘hold warm’ setting on your oven to hold it if you want to allow extra cooking time and it finishes early. Pastured turkeys stay really juicy, so I wouldn’t worry about it drying out.
Bird is frozen, not fresh
FRESH is a word best applied to vegetables. When it comes to meat, the proteolytic enzymes need time to help break down the meat and make it tender, so we must AGE everything. When turkeys are processed, we must chill them them a minimum of 24 hours before anything can be done with them (freezing, cooking or selling). At our farm, we freeze them. And there is absolutely NO change in quality. In fact, I don’t know why, but I think the frozen poultry has an improved texture over the fresh.
Here at Sap Bush, we now freeze ALL our turkeys for several reasons.
First, if we try to get to Thanksgiving with fresh turkeys, then we run the risk of having a weather incident that could kill the birds prematurely. We try to grow them in the part of the year when conditions are ideal – when the heat of summer abates, before the cold gets too brutal. Then there’s the growth thing….We’ve learned with turkeys in a natural system that we can PREDICT, but that we cannot CONTROL their growth rate. Like any creature, they’re all different. When we used to process fresh birds for Thanksgiving, we could end up with 30+ pound birds. People were freaked out.
So now, we pull them off as they appear ready, and harvest them. All of them are harvested within two weeks of Thanksgiving.
NOW, let’s talk about the “fresh” turkeys in the store. They LOOK fresh…but seriously: how could those birds be harvested on-demand from a farm (assuming it’s an ethically-raised organic/pastured turkey and not a factory bird) and magically show up on the date you need them completely fresh?
There’s a secret to that. The law states that poultry can be held INDEFINITELY at an internal temperature of 26 degrees Fahrenheit, which is neither fresh, nor frozen. Indefinitely. And THAT’s what gives them the ability to be labeled “fresh.” Those turkeys can be weeks or months old.
Spatchcocking the bird
2019 saw a rise in interest in the spatchcocking method; removing the back of the turkey, splaying it out breast-side-up, and roasting it. Sounds like a whole lotta extra work if you ask us, but okay. If that’s what you wanna do, go for it. Just make sure your bird, splayed out, will fit in your oven…Cuz we had folks write to us when they realized that a full-size turkey, splayed out like that, wouldn’t fit in the oven opening. Those who had small enough birds to pull it off reported their turkeys cooked 7 minutes per pound.